Hoarding is not collection development
Follow us on:
Categories
Making a Collection Count

Death in a Bottle

The Brown Bottle
Jones
1983

Submitter: Found this in storage (at least that’s our saving grace – this wasn’t on the shelf!) of a small town public library. I have now weeded it. It’s a picture book about a caterpillar who is an alcoholic. And dies instead of changing into a butterfly. While I get what they were going for, it’s sort of horrifying. What kind of person would read this to a small child??

Holly: WTF? Seriously. W. T. F.

More WTF:

I Want to Believe

You Are Such a Tight Ass

Partying…Horses?

Serial Killer Training Manual

16 Responses to Death in a Bottle

  • This is just sick. And not with alcoholism. . . the depths of the bottle hold the utopia he sought—the bottle didn’t care—the day of The Promise—this one needs to be shredded.

  • That’s a hell of a allegory for a child to wrap his or her head around. The writing is actually fairly effective and impactful, but I think it would be better served as a story specifically targeted to and read by teenage or adult alcoholics (or potential alcoholics). You wouldn’t even have to change the wording, just the book design.

  • I looked this book up on Amazon fully expecting to see horrible 1 and 2 star reviews. There were actually some thoughtful, ensightful comments. I guess you can’t always tell what kind of book will speak to someone. I wouldn’t hand this to a small child by any means, but it may have it’s place with someone.

    http://www.amazon.com/Brown-Bottle-Penny-Jones/dp/0894861700/ref=sr_1_1?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1434639548&sr=1-1&keywords=brown+bottle

  • I Googled it, too, and looked at more than Amazon. It looks like it was intended for families where alcoholism is a problem. Here’s a link to a link to a recovery message board that mentioned it: http://www.soberrecovery.com/forums/friends-family-alcoholics/248584-childrens-book-brown-bottle.html

    It’s also mentioned favorably on other alcohol recovery sites, and someone posted the entire text on an AA message board.

  • Growing up in an alcoholic home I didn’t need this book to see the affect of alcohol on the family. However, I think it is a worthy boom to make available. Who knows, it may save someone from a terrible lifestyle.

  • My first reaction to the book cover was, “What a cute picture, what could possibly be wrong with *reads description* ohhh my…!” O_O

  • Plus the artwork is so bloody awful it makes me want to drink….

  • Suggested musical accompaniment: “Golden Brown” by The Stranglers, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lkR_HafkYak

  • “Why YES! THAT’s Charlie! He turned into a green butterfly! He kept warm in a bottle all winter! When is library day?” (This is another 362.2 that shouldn’t be shelved in E)

  • Is this some sort of parody along the lines of “Go The Fuck To Sleep”?

  • The title reminds me of the “Little Brown Jug”, which has a completely opposite theme.

  • The publisher is listed as Hazelden, which presumably is associated with the rehab center. So it may have had some pretty specific audiences in mind. (The ’80s was also the era of this stuff.)

  • The thing you give to children of alcoholics is “the caterpillar dies alone”??? That’s not gonna mess them up or anything!

  • Wow. That is very deep, especially for a child! At first I thought it was going to be about a worm in the bottle of tequila. That in itself is not exactly a children’s story but my gosh. This is tragic!!

  • I grew up with two alcoholic parents and I did end up losing them both to alcoholism in my late twenties. This is a very powerful, poignant book but I’ll be darned if I’ll ever let my son, who was born after my parents were both already gone, see this even if he wants to know what happened to them. Just…wow.

  • Dear god that was bleaker than a Steve McQueen movie. (McQueen the director, not the actor…)
    It’s a strong message all right, but I really can’t fathom handing this to a child.