Hoarding is not collection development
Categories
Taking Your Library Career to the Next Level
PLA Weeding Manual
Making a Collection Count

Best Book Review Blogs” style=

The Book Blogger Awards 2017

Boy Scouts collect stamps

boy scouts stamps

Stamp Collecting
Boy Scouts of America
1993

I couldn’t believe that the date on this book was 1993. The pictures seem to be much older.  Stamp collecting is still a big hobby and there are many more current books on stamp collecting. I am not sure I would add this to the collection, unless there is a current need for scouting material. I hope the scouts have updated this particular book.

And then we have the back cover advertising a subscription to Boy’s Life. I guess the scouts are into some cultural appropriation after they get the stamp collections done.

Mary

boy scouts stamp collecting back cover

requirements of badge

learning the lingo

displaying your collection

11 Responses to Boy Scouts collect stamps

  • EXTREME SPORTS stamps, though! It’s MODERN!

  • I suppose the merit badge pamphlets were only partially edited before being re-issued. Of course it’s too old and should go, but I don’t see how you know that the Boys’ Life cover is of a white kid; he looks to me like a Native American kid in ceremonial dress.

    • He’ll be one of the Koshare Indian dancers- a Boy Scout group that carefully researches, learns, and presents Native American culture. It is a lot more respectful than, say, getting a sexy Indian costume for Halloween. Aside from performing and educating visitors, they teach the boys themselves about all the people whose history and culture they are learning about, and the crafts and skills in making the clothes (they make their own dress). https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Koshare_Indian_Museum_and_Dancers

  • Scouting merit badge books are updated regularly as requirements and information changes, but they don’t always update the photos. Looks like the latest update is from 2007.

  • The Boy Scouts have incorporated a lot of Native American traditions, and I know that in the 90s at least there was concern about doing so respectfully and getting it right. I’m not sure what their position is in this century, when cultural appropriation has come into the spotlight.

  • I used merit badge books in the 1980’s. They were indeed often reprints of much older editions.

    There is a long tradition of Boy Scouts dressing as Native Americans and appropriating (usually superficial) aspects of their cultures. For example, try an image search for “Order of the Arrow” or research the Koshare Indian Museum and Dancers (La Junta, Colorado — interesting museum). However, those appropriations were relatively respectful compared to how Indians were treated in older movies and films, not to mention write-ups in U.S. history textbooks and historical markers. Ex. https://www.flickr.com/photos/vanherdehaage/36055200870/in/album-72157683012022563/

  • Huh, looks like that book was from 1998, not 1993. And the article about the Indian dancers sure is something… http://media.boyslife.org/archive/#issue=M_8DAAAAMBAJ

  • Cover looks circa 1960.

  • That is not the current edition of the Stamp Collecting merit badge pamphlet. Entire series is updated regularly, especially when requirements change.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *